The GOAT is Retiring

[Nomad]

Montana was the best quarterback ever.  Brady has the most records.

[Jim_]

I'm another hater ... but he sure was great. Engineer so many late comebacks ... it would piss me off. lol. Pretty good for 44 years old, too.

When I was a little kid, for some reason I liked the Baltimore Colts. So, Johnny U still kinda my favorite QB.

Against the Giants at Yankee Stadium ...

 

[BHC]

Now he came out and said he isn't sure

[Mink]

I went from disliking him to just ok with him to really liking him .

[Bucndoe]

The GOAT's goat was a guy named Eli

[DBuck]

2 hours ago, Buckeyes11 said:

Montana was not better than Peyton Manning.  No way. 

The GOAT debate never even included Manning, it was always between Montana and Brady. Though Manning Holds more records, Joe has a higher winning percentage and was more clutch. The next thing you'll try to tell me is Eli was a good QB and belongs in the HOF 

https://www.nfl.com/news/top-25-quarterbacks-of-all-time-patriots-tom-brady-leads-list-0ap3000001035041

 

[DBuck]

49 minutes ago, Mink said:

I went from disliking him to just ok with him to really liking him .

Me too, always respected his play.

1 minute ago, Bucndoe said:

The GOAT's goat was a guy named Eli

The GOAT's Goat was the Giants Defense, certainly not Eli.

[midwestxpress]

He and his father said that report isn't true.

[DBuck]

4 minutes ago, midwestxpress said:

He and his father said that report isn't true.

I was going to post earlier that I'll believe it when I actually hear it from him

https://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2022/1/29/22908015/tom-brady-retires-nfl-22-tampa-bay-bucs-new-england-patriots

[Bucndoe]

7 minutes ago, DBuck said:

Me too, always respected his play.

The GOAT's Goat was the Giants Defense, certainly not Eli.

There were two different Giant Defenses in those games, but only one QB that beat him twice

[BHC]

can't spell Elite without spelling Eli.....who deserves to be in HOF

[Batsto]

This could be fake news started by that Juvenile Antonio Brown. We shall see! 

[Sako76]

Brady is 0-2 against the Giants and Eli in Super Bowls.

[Buckeyes11]

56 minutes ago, DBuck said:

The GOAT debate never even included Manning, it was always between Montana and Brady. Though Manning Holds more records, Joe has a higher winning percentage and was more clutch. The next thing you'll try to tell me is Eli was a good QB and belongs in the HOF 

https://www.nfl.com/news/top-25-quarterbacks-of-all-time-patriots-tom-brady-leads-list-0ap3000001035041

 

Montana was def clutch. Can’t deny that. 

[DBuck]

34 minutes ago, Bucndoe said:

There were two different Giant Defenses in those games, but only one QB that beat him twice

 2 different Defenses that were the main reason for both wins. Just look at the scores. 2008 17-14 , both QBs threw for less than 300 yards, the Giants had 5 sacks, and then you have Tyree's lucky helmet catch. If not for that catch, the Patriots win.  2012, again both QBs threw for under 300 yards. Both games were defensive battles. And no way should Eli have won MVP for eith game, but when you can't give it to the whole defense you give it to the QB.

45 minutes ago, BHC said:

can't spell Elite without spelling Eli.....who deserves to be in HOF

Did you really just call him elite??