I think a lot of the “problems” people have with scent lures in general is not knowing how and when to use them properly. In addition to that we do have an out of whack buck to doe ratio in this part of the country. It’s hard to beat the real thing.
That being said, Steve, the owner at Signal 11 is very knowledgeable and willing to share info on what, when and how to use his product. Also he bottles fresh without preservatives so it’s best to get a new bottle and refrigerate an open one. I have had some great success using Tramp Stamp and Scrape Nuggets as well as Sweet Dreams. I have had multiple bucks come in on a string following a drag and my mock scrapes taken over by pissed off bucks. No, it doesn’t work every time, but that’s why it’s hunting. If my shooting was half as good we’d be in business lol.