POLL Adult Deer Contest Buck Scoring (ROUND 2)

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

OK, the other topic is a mix of options, so we're doing Round 2 of polling.  Season is fast approaching, so if we want to have a contest we have to narrow down on the rule set.

Please vote in the poll, you can select multiples if you are open to several! 

[rgw 4,415]

This is how the hunting store by me does it every year. 

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

bump, I'll probably let this run for a couple days and then go with the majority.

[JHbowhunter 15,909]

5 minutes ago, BowhunterNJ said:

bump, I'll probably let this run for a couple days and then go with the majority.

hope it goes off this year - surprised nobody wanted to just measure the rack the right way...  I would be all for just keeping it simple I suppose... Spread plus points...  It's  a built in bias toward long ass tined narrow bucks and bucks with a lot of mass, but nobody cares so let it go...    I just did not understand why there was a cut-off after 17" in the original scoring?

[Buck154 14,459]

I think keep it the way it was but change the spread part to give a point for every inch they are wide (inside Spread).  This way a 16.5" buck and a 24" wide don't get the same credit.

The one problem with the longest beam and longest tine is that there is no way to show a picture to prove the actual length of a beam and some guys will have a tendency to stretch it a little. The tine length can be seen in a picture with a tape but not the beam. So if you have where those measurements are needed then just make it where the rack should be brought out to a Woods and Water get together and measured.

Keep the teams as some guys/gals might not have the best land to hunt so a combined with random picked teams is good for all. Luck of the draw.

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

Leading the way:  Number of points + actual width measurement + longest tine on left beam + longest tine on right beam

Agree on the error measuring lengths can introduce, but hopefully everyone does it honestly and the additional measurements should give enough variance to scores where we don't see any significance in the impact of errors.  Stretching it should be 1/2" +/- per measurement, not 2-3" per measurement.

The reality is, it's not like everyone is entering 20 bucks a season...in all likelihood many would be fortunate to get 1 or maybe even 2.  Over the course of hunting for months, taking a few minutes (even with cold hands @Lunatic  ) shouldn't be a big deterrent.  

 

[Lunatic 19,179]

34 minutes ago, BowhunterNJ said:

Leading the way:  Number of points + actual width measurement + longest tine on left beam + longest tine on right beam

Agree on the error measuring lengths can introduce, but hopefully everyone does it honestly and the additional measurements should give enough variance to scores where we don't see any significance in the impact of errors.  Stretching it should be 1/2" +/- per measurement, not 2-3" per measurement.

The reality is, it's not like everyone is entering 20 bucks a season...in all likelihood many would be fortunate to get 1 or maybe even 2.  Over the course of hunting for months, taking a few minutes (even with cold hands @Lunatic  ) shouldn't be a big deterrent.  

 

I appreciate the concern for my delicate hands and I agree on the rest

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

More votes coming in!

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

bump, will be setting up the contest soon

[nmc02 3,841]

By weight

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

8 minutes ago, nmc02 said:

By weight

Weigh-ins to be held at @nmc02's house!  Woohoo!

[Lphunsjr 3,191]

I'm still lost

[BowhunterNJ 10,499]

Just now, Lphunsjr said:

I'm still lost

Right now the leading option for Buck Scoring is:  Number of points + actual width measurement + longest tine on left beam + longest tine on right beam

Count the points and add those three measurements

Example:  8 pointer with 20" inside spread, 11" right G2 and 9" left G3 = 8 + 20 + 11 + 9 = 48 points

[Rusty 15,168]

26 minutes ago, BowhunterNJ said:

Weigh-ins to be held at @nmc02's house!  Woohoo!

WOO HOO,  been there done that.  

[JHbowhunter 15,909]

1 hour ago, Lphunsjr said:

I'm still lost

Larry don’t worry if what was your target buck last year made it to this year - this method you will win!  Oh and you can use a calculator.